A Privilege, Not a Right. Who Decided That?

Illustration: a velvet rope and red carpet in front of a big blue bank building while a small green crypto bank and coins wait outside, on a warm pink-to-orange background

Written by

in

On Monday, the Supreme Court declined to hear Custodia Bank’s case against the Federal Reserve. No comment. No noted dissent. Six years of fighting for a master account, the account that lets a bank plug straight into the dollar system, ended with one line on a court docket.

Within hours, the Bank Policy Institute had a statement out. BPI speaks for the country’s biggest banks. Its take: the court “wisely” left in place a ruling that a Fed master account “is a privilege, not a right.”

Sit with that phrase for a second.

What happened

Custodia is a Wyoming-chartered crypto bank founded by Caitlin Long. It applied for a master account in October 2020. The Kansas City Fed said no in January 2023, citing concerns about its crypto-focused business. The lower courts sided with the Fed, ruling that regional Fed banks have discretion to turn down even eligible banks. By refusing the case, the Supreme Court let that ruling stand. It did not decide who was right.

The fair point

Let’s be fair. The Fed’s job is to keep the payment system safe. BPI argues that uninsured banks with new business models get lighter supervision and could create risk for everyone else. Custodia’s deposits are not FDIC-insured. A regulator being careful with the dollar’s core plumbing is not a scandal.

Look who’s cheering

But look at who showed up. BPI and The Clearing House, another big-bank group, filed briefs backing the Fed at several stages of the case, BPI says in its own statement. That’s the incumbents arguing that a newcomer shouldn’t be guaranteed the same door they already walk through. When the people inside the club help shape the guest list, you’re allowed to ask questions.

And “privilege” is a loaded word. A privilege is something someone hands out. Somebody decides, case by case, and now no court is going to second-guess them. Kraken’s Wyoming bank got its master account in March, after what Kraken calls more than five years of regulatory engagement. Custodia, same state, same kind of charter, got a no and a six-year court fight. Maybe there are good reasons for the difference. The public mostly doesn’t get to see them.

My speculation

Here’s where I go further, and I’m labeling it as speculation. I think the master account is the real moat in American finance. Stablecoins, tokenized deposits, 24/7 settlement: every one of those businesses gets cheaper and safer with a direct line to the Fed, and pricier and shakier without one. Without it, a crypto bank rents access from a bigger bank, and that bank can raise the rent or close the account. If I ran a big bank, a court saying “you can’t force your way in” is exactly what I’d want. I can’t prove that’s what the lobbying is really about, and nobody has said it out loud. But follow the incentives.

There’s a consolation prize on the table. Fed Governor Christopher Waller has floated a slimmed-down “skinny” master account for newer firms, and the Fed’s draft would pay no interest on balances and allow no borrowing at its discount window, according to The Block. Custodia told the Supreme Court that kind of limited account isn’t enough, Bloomberg reported. My guess, again labeled: skinny accounts become the standard offer for crypto firms. Enough to plug in. Not enough to compete head-on with the banks already inside.

What’s left

The courts are out of it now. That leaves the Fed and Congress, where Sen. Cynthia Lummis of Wyoming backed Custodia’s case. If you think access to the dollar’s front door shouldn’t depend on whether the gatekeepers like your business model, that’s where to make noise.

A privilege can be granted. It can also be taken away. That’s the whole point of calling it one.

Sources: Supreme Court of the United States, Bank Policy Institute, The Block, Bloomberg, Kraken, Unchained, Hardwire (Nov. 17).